You don’t need to spend a lot of money to give a great bourbon gift. Many excellent bottles cost under $60 and still offer great flavor, quality, and personality. In this price range, you’ll find a mix of classic brands, craft distilleries, and revived heritage names—all making impressive bourbon that feels special without being expensive.
The under-$60 bourbon category is better than ever. Well-known brands continue to deliver reliable options, while newer distilleries bring fresh ideas and bold flavors. Whether the gift is for a long-time bourbon fan or someone new to whiskey, these bottles show that you can enjoy amazing bourbon without paying a high price.
Starlight Distillery Carl T Bourbon Small Batch
Starlight Distillery is known for making high-quality whiskey from grain to bottle, and its Carl T Small Batch is one of the best affordable bourbons you can buy. It’s made from a mix of 3-grain and 4-grain recipes, giving it warm and comforting flavors like caramel apple, cinnamon, toasted oak, and gentle sweetness—flavors Starlight fans love.
This bottle also comes with a great story. The distillery began as a family farm and has built a strong reputation for careful barrel aging and true, hands-on craftsmanship. It feels like a thoughtful, meaningful gift while still staying under $60.
1792 Small Batch Straight Bourbon
1792 Small Batch is a long-time favorite among bourbon fans. People recommend it when you want something bold, well-made, and reasonably priced. The high-rye recipe gives it a strong, spicy character, with flavors of clove, black pepper, caramel, and smoky oak. Even with these bold flavors, it finishes smooth and balanced. It’s a great choice for anyone who enjoys spicy and complex bourbon. The stylish bottle also makes it look more expensive than it is. For experienced bourbon drinkers, this is a gift that shows good taste without spending too much.
Eagle Rare Kentucky Straight Bourbon
bigtreebottles
Very few bourbons under $60 offer the same elegance as Eagle Rare. It is aged for 10 years and made with the careful craftsmanship Buffalo Trace is known for. You’ll taste orange peel, honey, vanilla, and oak, with a clean and smooth finish. It’s one of those rare bourbons that almost everyone loves—collectors appreciate its quality, and beginners enjoy how smooth it is. It can be hard to find sometimes, but if you spot it for under $60, you’ve found one of the best bourbon gifts available.
Wheel Horse Cigar Blend Bourbon
wheelhorsewhiskey
Wheel Horse’s Cigar Blend is bold and full of flavor—a rich bourbon perfect for long evenings, late-night chats, or anyone who enjoys whiskey with character. It has notes of caramel, dark spice, chocolate, and oak, finishing strong enough to pair nicely with a cigar. It feels special without being expensive. If you want a gift for someone who likes a deep, full-bodied bourbon, this is a top choice under $60.
Templeton Fortitude Bourbon
thewhiskeywash
Templeton Whiskey from Iowa is famous for its rye, but the Fortitude bourbon brings the same mix of sweetness and spice in a modern style. You’ll notice flavors like dried fruit, vanilla, brown sugar, and warm baking spices—great to drink straight or in a holiday cocktail. If you’re unsure what kind of bourbon someone likes, this bottle is a safe, reliable choice.
Rabbit Hole Cavehill Kentucky Straight Bourbon
whiskeyinmyweddingring
Cavehill is a unique bourbon that usually costs under $60 (though sometimes a bit more). Its four-grain mix gives it bright, rich flavors without being too heavy. The name comes from Louisville’s Cave Hill Cemetery, where many famous Kentucky distillers are buried—a nice connection between Rabbit Hole’s modern style and traditional bourbon roots. You’ll notice flavors of orchard fruits, toasted grains, honey, and warm spices, making it a thoughtful gift for anyone who enjoys trying something beyond the usual Kentucky bourbon.
O.H. Ingram River Aged Uncharted Wheated Bourbon
seelbachs
O.H. Ingram takes bourbon in a new direction by aging it in a floating rickhouse on the Mississippi River. The river’s motion, changing humidity, and temperature swings speed up how the whiskey interacts with the wood, giving it a unique texture and rich flavor. Their new Uncharted Wheated Bourbon lets fans taste what judges have been raving about. With such an interesting story behind it, this bourbon makes a gift that’s sure to start great conversations.
Published: 12th December 2025
For more such articles, please follow us on Twitter, Linkedin & Instagram
Also Read:
Common hidden money errors that slow your business growth
Trump launches $1m ‘Gold Card’ immigration visas
Why Return on Work Is the Secret to a High-Value Business Exit
